picking favorites 1

I recently went through a ghost stories phase that lasted for months. To share some of the knowledge I gained from that experience I wrote a post about trends in scary children’s literature, which you can access here. For each trend I gave a couple examples and ended up sharing over 10 book recommendations. That’s when I noticed something—I’ve read a lot of creepy kid’s books. But no matter how much fun I had reading all of them, only a few were actually excellent.

So what makes the difference between “fun” and “favorite”? When it comes to my library reads, I try to judge a book against some standard criteria before putting it on my favorites list. Here are a few of the things I look for when reading children’s books:

  • The characters (whether they have special powers or not) act like actual children.
  • The writing style is smooth and engaging.
  • I can follow the first chapter without feeling frustrated by the introduction of too many unexplained characters or situations.
  • The author knows how to add depth by including several dimensions to the central problem without being overwhelming.
  • The motivations and reactions of the characters feel real.
  • Descriptions add to my imagination’s picture rather than confuse me.
  • If it’s trying to be funny, it actually succeeds.

If a book fulfills these requirements, then there’s a good chance it has some other great characteristics that will make it a favorite. So which of my scary reads made it on the list? Well I’ll give you one: CORALINE, of course! You may have seen that one coming, but if you haven’t read it yet, check it out. Neil Gaiman is a master of his craft. This book meets all of my criteria; plus, it’s freaky.

7.26 CoralineCORALINE
By Neil Gaiman






Provo Library Blog

Your daily stop for recommendations, reviews, and random facts about the Provo City Library. Look for new content every week day. 

Blog Contributors

Other Blogs

Library Staff Reviews 

Children's Book Reviews